Buchbauer & McGuire, P.C. - Winchester, Virginia

Lauren M.

I’m incredibly grateful to Mr. McGuire for handling the custody portion of my divorce with such care, professionalism, and efficiency. From the beginning, I felt genuinely supported—he not only took care of every detail, but also made sure I felt reassured throughout the process. It meant so much to have someone in my corner who clearly had everything under control.

Compared to my out-of-state divorce attorney, working with Mr. McGuire was both significantly more affordable and far more efficient. He was fair with his time, consistently followed through, and made a difficult situation feel manageable. I also have to mention Tanya—she was an absolute joy to work with. Together, they’re truly a dream team.

What stood out even more was his reputation. Everyone I encountered in the county had nothing but amazing things to say about him. He’s clearly well-liked, highly respected, and trusted in the legal community—and my experience reflected exactly why.

I walked away with everything I wanted. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend Mr. McGuire to anyone in need of legal representation. He’s everything you hope for in an attorney: trustworthy, competent, and genuinely caring.

Brenda L.

Mr. McGuire is the absolute best! I was so impressed with his level of professionalism, accuracy, and promptness. I found comfort in knowing that our case was in such knowledgeable and capable hands. Not only he is an excellent Attorney, but he also truly cares about his clients and works hard at achieving the best outcome, all while remaining very kind and genuine. I am beyond grateful to have had his representation. His assistant Tanya is equally just as amazing. They were both prompt in their responses and were extremely patient and understanding. I never felt rushed or pressured. I would highly recommend this Firm and would definitely use them again, should the need arise.

Robert S.

If it were possible to give zero stars, this would be a zero. My daughter hired Ms. Devon Humphreys of this firm to handle a custody issue. During the course of her representation, she gave late and erroneous advice that resulted in serious, negative results in my daughter's case in addition to costing a ridiculous amount of money. On the day of trial, Ms. Humphries withdrew because we wanted an explanation for a late change in advice that she had no explanation for and chose to withdraw instead. After the withdrawal, several attorneys suggested that the conduct in this case could be considered malpractice. Ms. Humphries advised my daughter to compromise her claim for terms that were far less favorable than those eventually achieved by new counsel. Save yourself the time and money and look elsewhere.

Anna T.

Mr. McGuire was my divorce attorney. He and his office were overall very personable and respectful. My divorce was contentious, as most are, and James handled each frustrating exchange with a calm that carried over- resulting in me feeling relaxed and confident about the end game. You will spend a good deal of $$ here, that being said, he and his office have a great reputation for good reason. He is patient, knowledgeable, responsive, has incredible listening skills, hardworking and advocated for me and my children. Areas to improve on are perhaps… stocking a bourbon bar for those not so great moments of break-down or there paying his bill or even a celebratory “cheers to getting your life back lady”. Seriously—these situations have no winner, it’s a zero sum game. However, I highly recommend. I enjoyed James’s personality and humor & his assistant, Tanya is an absolute delight to work with. I hope I never need him again as my pockets are quite thinned, but I am pleased with the outcome-smiling while typing this.

Mahala G.

Peter Buchbauer is simply the best. He and his very adept team skillfully guided me through a very challenging 1 and 1/2 year journey to divorce. At every twist and turn, Mr Buchbauer communicated clearly, compassionately, and pragmatically with me. I was kept up to date, was involved in strategic decisions regarding the case, and made fully aware of best and worse case scenarios. He prepared me. In the end, I had a front row seat and was able to witness this consummate, passionate professional advocate for my best interests.
I am so very grateful to have had Mr Buchbauer and his team working for me.

Charleen D.

Mr. McGuire was fantastic and the best divorce attorney. He was thorough, prepared and knew how to approach each step of what ended up being a 2 year journey. He provided much needed guidance during a very difficult time in my life. I'd be remiss if I didn't mention Tanya Snyder. Tanya was kind and helpful during the process and helped set my mind at ease.

Lou A. T.

Mr. Vance represented me and I was able to regain visitation with my granddaughter. Mr. Vance handled every detail and kept me apprised of each detail. Highly recommend Mr. Vance !!

Kayla S.

Mr. McGuire and his assistant, Tanya, were very helpful and knowledgeable throughout my husband’s case. Mr. McGuire was able to get my husband everything he was asking for, including full physical custody of his daughter. Mr. McGuire was a CHAMP in the courtroom, he was always one step ahead of the game and he knew all of the right questions to ask while on the stand. He truly fought for what is in the best interest of my sweet bonus baby! Thank you to this team for all of their efforts in this case!